I got Duncan ahead of Bird.. Magic is NOT better either IMO.. To me it is only really Jordan, and Kareem.. Maybe Wilt.. Let the old farts prattle on for content. Tim has 5 rings and 3 finals MVP awards.. And had to beat Shaq, Kobe, Lebron, Dirk etc to get them.. But I doubt Jok wins another ring unless he loads up with a Superteam..
Yeah, I don't think Magic's truly in that tier because of defense. Gotta be elite at both sides to be in the convo imo. Everyone else on the list were either perineal All-D guys or at least top5 DPOY at their peak or in the case of Wilt over 20 rebs and likely over/way over 5 blocks.
Magic was the 1st unicorn, could legit play every position. Huge credit for winning the finals as a rook filling in as Center with Kareem hurt. and putting up 40/15 playing C in an easy win.
That really helped cement his brand, the guy everyone loved who could do anything, the great smile and best nickname ever.
I do think Magic would dominate todays game though, Luka like without the constant bitching. Dude always played at a fast pace, incredible BBIQ + passing and when he started shooting 3s at the end, he was about 36%. If he grew up today I think he'd be a 50/40/90 guy, put up 48/38.4/89 in his 2nd to last full season.
My Dad's from LA, still get Showtime discussions at family reunions. There will never be a team of better nicknames, such great branding. Showtime with Riles as Coach Slick leading Magic, Cap, Ice Man, Iron Man, Lord Byron, Rambo, and Coop!